Forum Discussion

flambeau's avatar
flambeau
New Contributor III
8 days ago

Cox doesn't actually provide the internet speeds I pay for

Okay, this is my third time writing about this on this forum. At this point, it's getting ridiculous. I pay for gigabit internet, which includes 35mbps upload rate. Except for the last 2 months I am unable to keep even 6mbps upload rate steady for my twitch streams. The first month I had absolutely no issues with my rates and then all the sudden when I begin streaming (ALL WITHIN MY DATA LIMITS) i begin to get throttled. I am sick and tired of having unreliable, inconsistent upload rates. I have tried unlimited data. I've tried gigabit. I started off with 500mbps and 10mbps upload speeds for my plan, it worked perfectly fine, then the upload rate quit being consistent and I started upgrading my service to try and bribe my way into having the ability to stream to twitch. Why on earth am i paying for gigabit internet (only need it for the upload) and not getting anywhere close to the advertised speeds. Why does cloudflare speedtest not come close to the official ookla ones? I had a bit of a buzz in the game I was streaming, I was building something of value for myself, and of all things my internet connection (WHICH SHOULD BE MORE THAN GOOD ENOUGH) has held me back from actually pursuing this any further. I've had techs come out. I've reached out to customer support and they reset my modem. I've done everything. My only solution at this point would be to literally move and change providers which just isn't in the cards. 

  • flambeau's avatar
    flambeau
    New Contributor III

    I mean seriously... I am paying for 1gig internet and I get 133mbps down and 3.78mbps up? This is absolutely ridiculous and I should just downgrade my internet because I have NEVER actually gotten any faster speeds from upgrading. Pointless. I wish another company with fiber was available in my area. This is just robbery. 

  • Hi,

    I apologize you are continuing to experience trouble with our service. I dont stream on Twitch but I do use my service daily while working from home so I can understand the importance of a reliable connection.Hi we do not limit speeds or throttle the connection when you reach the data plan. Slow speeds are normally caused by some type of signal interference or a bad connection.  Please contact us privately so we can investigate further. our email address is cox.help@cox.com Please include your name full street address and a link to this forum post. 

    Greg

    • flambeau's avatar
      flambeau
      New Contributor III

      I have had a tech come out already about this. They said everything looks like it should be working fine but it clearly wasn't. So he cancelled the appointment. I have no idea what on earth could be interfering with my signal when I am using an ethernet cable.

      All my frame drops are due to network. And the percentage slowly rises. BTW I am paying for 35MBPS upload rates, getting less than 5. Might as well have dial up. This has happened for months. This began about 1 month after I first started streaming. Now I am exhausted and have given up trying to make this work. I haven't done a stream in like a week+ and my buzz is falling off, i don't feel theres any point in me trying to even stream anymore because I just end up mad that im paying for service i dont actually get. I have went unlimited data, i've upgraded my speeds, and none of it is working. I bought a new modem even to be able to get gigabit internet.

  • flambeau's avatar
    flambeau
    New Contributor III

    After 10mins live.. 

    1/5 of my stream has failed to upload, still with atrocious upload rates for "gigabit" internet.

  • Hi,

    With the dropped frames. I would want to test to see if there's also packet loss when not streaming. a program like Ping Plotter is a good way to test this it will let us know if there is packet loss and where the packet loss is occurring.

    Greg

    • flambeau's avatar
      flambeau
      New Contributor III

      I have PingPlotter for 14 days, I did traceroutes for twitch last time. What exactly do I do in PingPlotter to get the information you need?

    • DorisM's avatar
      DorisM
      Moderator

      Please email my team at cox.help@cox.com. Thank you for being a part of the Cox community. 

  • WiderMouthOpen's avatar
    WiderMouthOpen
    Esteemed Contributor

    What model modem do you have and what is your speed connected directly to that modem? Also, what are your modem signal levels from 192.168.100.1? If your upload is slow, there's probably something wrong with your upstream signal.

    • flambeau's avatar
      flambeau
      New Contributor III

      I have a Hitron Coda-56 modem. I actually only purchased this modem to upgrade to DOCSIS 3.1, because my previous modem (Surfboard SB6190) had the same issue. So the speeds I am getting when directly connected to the modem are ~200mb down and 4.9mb up. I am unable to even access my modem's admin page to see the signal strength and such - but I have had a tech come out and confirm all of it looked fine.. There was a tech who came out a few weeks ago who looked over my entire set up and said there was nothing wrong and that I shouldn't be getting the issues that I was (he saw in person that it wasn't working). His conclusion was that everything was fine, the lines looked fine, and there must be a "Node" around me that was having intermittent issues.. He ultimately said he "cancelled" the appointment and left. 

       

      I've already decided to downgrade my service back down to my original speeds - 250mb down, 12mb up, because I streamed using this speed fine for a month before my upload rates all the sudden began to drop and be inconsistent and unreliable. I upgraded my service, data plan, purchased a new modem, and none of it actually helped so I've exhausted everything and have given up and reverted to my old speed and told people not to expect me to be active anymore. I've tried to stream for a week now and everyday when I get all set up I hit the go live button just to see my ISP fleecing me.

       So the speeds I am getting when directly connected to the modem are ~200mb down and 4.9mb up. I am unable to even access my modem's admin page to see the signal strength and such - but I have had a tech come out and confirm all of it looked fine. Moreover, speaking with cox help, they only take ookla speed test results which showed 30mbps upload rate, but every single other speed test and in actual practice I was only getting 4mb upload speeds. Then cox help proceeded to inform me it must be twitch servers that have the issue.. Which is ridiculous because there are thousands of people streaming without issue at any moment on that site.

       

      The first time I reached out about this, they said there must be "noise" on my line or have bad lines, so they scheduled a tech to look, which ended up with the tech basically shrugging his shoulders, saying it should work, but he sees that it doesn't, and there's nothing more that he can do to resolve my issue. I am so tired of dealing with this, it throws my mood completely off every time I encounter it because I have tried so many things, spent hundreds of dollars between a new modem and extra data/better service, and have gotten absolutely nowhere.

      • WiderMouthOpen's avatar
        WiderMouthOpen
        Esteemed Contributor

        Ouch, you went from a modem that has a lemon of a CPU(google Puma6) to one that overheats and is difficult to access it's diagnostics. You need to set a static IP and bypass your router. See here.

        As for what the technician said, either something is wrong on your end or Cox's end. I think looking at the actual data is important. 

        The fact that it happened around a upgrade probably means it has something to do with the downstream OFDM channel(s) or upstream OFDMA channel. Noise, or a low SNR, could have something to do with it.

        What does Cox's speed test show you? That should be what Cox looks at the most. That shows you what speed you are getting on Cox's network. Cox can only control performance on their network. If the problem is between them and the Twitch servers, there isn't much they can/will do.

        If technicians aren't fixing the problem, I would try a FCC complaint. But isolating what and when the problem is, is important.

  • flambeau's avatar
    flambeau
    New Contributor III

    https://forums.cox.com/discussions/internet/upload-speeds-drop-at-the-same-exact-time-every-night-for-months/127309

    This is eerily similar to my issue. I'm pretty sure this is just an issue where cox isn't allocating enough resources to my local node. Either way, this has been a consistent issue for going on months now.

    • WiderMouthOpen's avatar
      WiderMouthOpen
      Esteemed Contributor

      The post you referenced was 5 years ago, before DOCSIS 3.1 really took off. There is more upload bandwidth these days so issues like that aren't as common. Your area would have to be very populated and oversold for that to be a issue to the extent you are having. Also, seem to be having a upload AND a download problem. If it is congestion on the node, there isn't much you can do except file a FCC complaint and hope Cox does a node split, but that is unlikely since it's expensive. Hoping signal data gives more clues on the root cause.

  • flambeau's avatar
    flambeau
    New Contributor III

    Submitting an FCC complaint about the issue now

  • Hi

    We want to help get the issue fixed. On at least some of the ping plotter tests, there is packet loss on the first few hops. Please email us at cox.help@cox.com so we can test your modem. 

    Greg

    • flambeau's avatar
      flambeau
      New Contributor III

      Here is a chart showing my bitrate performance from a twitch stream last night. All the sudden at 1:20am, hours after beginning my stream, the upload rate began working. This is why I think the node is oversaturated because all times besides really late night/early morning, the upload rate just doesn't perform well. 

       

      You can see i was stuck at 4-5mbps for a large portion of the stream in the beginning. 

      it would be like really cool if i could actually pursue this as I have been doing mildly well with streaming. The bitrate thing is really holding me back. I specifically chose to stream really late because it seems like when everyone is typically asleep the network works fine

      • DorisM's avatar
        DorisM
        Moderator

        Please email my team at cox.help@cox.com. Thank you for being a part of the Cox community.