Show's being recorded because the guide is incorrectly listing them as "Live"
I've seen this multiple times on various channels. Tomorrow my DVR has multiple baseball games scheduled to be recorded on channel 407 because the guide has them listed as "Live" when in fact they're actually repeats.
This appears as if you may need someone to look into your account personally. We would definitely be able to assist you with this. Please reach us on Twitter at @CoxHelp, visit us on Facebook, or email us at firstname.lastname@example.org. Provide us the name on the account with the complete service address with a link to this thread so we can get started.