Forum Discussion

Les_Rain's avatar
Les_Rain
New Contributor
6 years ago
Solved

Gigablast/Fiber/Traceroute

Upgraded to Gigablast fiber in AZ a little less than a month ago and everything is working great.

However, I'm curious about the results I always get from traceroute commands. Since this change every site I traceroute to (IPV4) is always 3 hops.  It doesn't matter where in the world it's located, it's always 3 hops.

It doesn't matter what tool I use (Windows 'tracert', winmtr, Linux mtr/traceroute) it's always 3 hops.

Here's an example of one to www.berlin.de

> tracert berlin.de

Tracing route to berlin.de [212.45.111.17]
over a maximum of 30 hops:

1 2 ms 2 ms 3 ms ip72-210-58-1.ph.ph.cox.net [72.210.58.1]
2 2 ms 2 ms 2 ms wsip-184-178-206-100.ph.ph.cox.net [184.178.206.100]
3 160 ms 160 ms 160 ms www.berlin.de [212.45.111.17]

Trace complete.

I'm guessing a network guru on here can easily tell me why (whether or not I can understand it is a different issue).

TIA

  • It's MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching).

    It's a standard to direct packets in a wide area IP network.

    It operates between OSI Layer-2 (data link) and Layer-3 (network).  It's often referred to as a layer 2.5 protocol.

    Service providers (Cox) deploy MPLS to support service level agreements with guarantee bandwidths (Gigablast).

    From the white paper, Revealing MPLS Tunnels Obscured from Traceroute:

    "It is well known that MPLS clouds may potentially lead to inaccurate and incomplete Internet maps when performing active measurements using traceroute.  In particular, MPLS tunnels may either obscure the underlying path or be incorrectly classified as direct IP links (between IP routers that are not physically adjacent)."

    Since switching to Gigablast with MPLS, the paths on the edge of the Cox network will be obscured within a link-layer tunnel.  Since it's below Layer-3, there will be no ICMP messages.  No ICMP messages...no recorded hops.

7 Replies

Replies have been turned off for this discussion
  • Bruce's avatar
    Bruce
    Honored Contributor III

    It's MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching).

    It's a standard to direct packets in a wide area IP network.

    It operates between OSI Layer-2 (data link) and Layer-3 (network).  It's often referred to as a layer 2.5 protocol.

    Service providers (Cox) deploy MPLS to support service level agreements with guarantee bandwidths (Gigablast).

    From the white paper, Revealing MPLS Tunnels Obscured from Traceroute:

    "It is well known that MPLS clouds may potentially lead to inaccurate and incomplete Internet maps when performing active measurements using traceroute.  In particular, MPLS tunnels may either obscure the underlying path or be incorrectly classified as direct IP links (between IP routers that are not physically adjacent)."

    Since switching to Gigablast with MPLS, the paths on the edge of the Cox network will be obscured within a link-layer tunnel.  Since it's below Layer-3, there will be no ICMP messages.  No ICMP messages...no recorded hops.

  • Bruce's avatar
    Bruce
    Honored Contributor III

    Are you using a VPN or NAT?  Looking at the RTT between 2 and 3, you can tell there's more info.  Try pathping berlin.de

    • Les_Rain's avatar
      Les_Rain
      New Contributor

      Thanks for responding Bruce. Yes, it sure seems like there's more info there.

      Definitely using NAT, but pathping returns the same result, with the addition of my local host at the top of the list.

      Also, I get the same 3 hops when tracing directly from my firewall (pfsense).

  • Bruce's avatar
    Bruce
    Honored Contributor III

    What else is new beside your Gigablast service...router, Virtual Manager, multiple firewalls?

    • Les_Rain's avatar
      Les_Rain
      New Contributor

      Nothing else changed. Again, it's not a problem, I'm just curious as to why.

      • Bruce's avatar
        Bruce
        Honored Contributor III

        With the exception of anything on cox.net and your requested destination (Berlin), something is blocking all other ICMP messages.  Could be your router, firewall or another firewall.

        I doubt everything between hops 2 and 3 is a network switch or blocking ICMP requests, and you're not receiving timeouts.  It is curious.